Jim Johnstone of Boardman(YSU hat) watches as his kids(from left), …

Special to The Vindicator | published: December 31, 2017

Jim Johnstone of Boardman(YSU hat) watches as his kids(from left), Ryley(10), Hayley(8) and Brayden(5) decorate cookies during First Night Youngstown, Sunday, Dec. 31, 2017, at One Hot Cookie in Youngstown. ..(Nikos Frazier | The Vindicator)