43
TNT’s ‘I Hate Hamlet’ is entertaining
By Lorraine spencer
“Shakespeare is algebra onstage,” says Gary Lefkowitz in Paul Rudnick’s “I Hate Hamlet.” If that is true, what is modern comedy? Remedial math? Or perhaps something more fun, such as gym class or recess.
In its latest incarnation at the Trumbull New Theatre, “I Hate Hamlet” proves to be more entertaining than algebra, but perhaps not as energetic as recess.
“I Hate Hamlet” is a comedy set in 1972, centered on an actor and his entourage. Andrew Rally is famous for his role as a young doctor on a TV medical drama. Upon his show’s cancellation, Andy decides to move to New York and give “real theater” a try. In a twist of theatrical fate, he ends up living in the apartment of deceased theater great John Barrymore. When Andy doubts his own ability to perform the lead role in Shakespeare’s “Hamlet,” Barrymore’s ghost appears to help him along.
Like many comedies of this ilk, the script is full of slightly ridiculous characters and memorable zingers. Lisa J. Bennett’s cast had the audience laughing throughout the evening.
Tim McGinley gave the night’s standout performance as the incarnation of aged lothario John Barrymore. Full of confidence and pomp, McGinley practically floated about the stage, filling every space with his smooth voice as he gave Andy advice and confidence.
Robert Marlin played Andrew Rally with an insecurity appropriate to his character. His transformations from uncertain actor to proud star and back were heartfelt and authentic. Marlin seemed natural onstage, regardless of his character’s unease.
As Deidre, Rally’s girlfriend, Maria Wright was over-the-top. Her sweet ing nue role seemed a little forced, and though her delivery was spot-on, her characterization was far from natural. Lois Schneider, as Felicia, the real-estate agent, and Micky Burnsworth, the talent agent, added support, though neither left a lasting impression on the audience and Burnsworth’s attempt at a German accent left something to be desired.
David Schneider added some spark to the show with his portrayal of Hollywood director Gary Peter Lefkowitz. His smooth-talking and quick-tongued – if dim-witted – character kept the action moving whenever he came onstage.
Any director will agree that in a comedy, pacing is everything. Comedies must be quick and light, something the cast of “I Hate Hamlet” still needs to work on. After a slow start with Act One, the cast seemed to pick up the pace in Act Two. Hopefully, the more the cast performs the show, the more they will succeed at quickening the pace. Those who attend the show in the next two weekends are sure to be entertained.
“I Hate Hamlet” continues Friday, Saturday and May 20 and 21 at 8 p.m. and May 23 at 3 p.m.