HOW HE SEES IT Fanaticism at work



By JAY AMBROSE
SCRIPPS HOWARD NEWS SERVICE
Something fanatical is at work in the war of Michael Newdow against the words "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance, and nothing points that up better than a comparison he made before the Supreme Court last week.
Excising those words from the pledge, he said, would be akin to the court's 1954 decision to end racial segregation in the schools in Brown v. Board of Education .
"Aren't we better off because we got rid of that stuff?" he asked.
Why, yes, of course we are, because what was going on was a horror in which literally millions of children were treated as if the color of their skin would somehow contaminate children whose skin was of a different color.
In violation of the Constitution's pledge of equality under the law, black children were required to go to different public schools than white children -- and almost always to inferior schools. School segregation had the consequence of limiting opportunities, of drawing a don't-cross circle around human potentiality.
Modern case
So skip ahead to the case in which Newdow is now arguing that the Constitution has been abridged because his daughter recites the pledge in a public school classroom. The harm to her is what exactly? If she doesn't want to participate, she doesn't have to. Or she can say all the words in the pledge except the two that upset her father. Is she thereby indoctrinated into some state-sponsored religion, as prohibited by the Constitution? Obviously not. Is she embarrassed? It seems unlikely.
And when you read his words and those of some of the justices interrogating him this past week, the issue turns out to be more about Newdow than about her.
He is her biological father. He never married the mother, who is a Christian with absolutely no objection to the child acknowledging God in the pledge. The issue is whether his child should hear two words that he does not want her to hear.
"I am an atheist," he said in court. "I don't believe in God. And every school morning my child is asked to stand up, face that flag, put her hand over her heart, and say that her father is wrong."
On this basis, then, the court should undo the work of Congress in 1954 to insert the words?
Newdow -- a physician and lawyer -- is offended, and although 90 percent of Americans say in a poll that they want the words to stay, he and those who support him believe the offense to him and others in like position is so significant that the court should rid the pledge of this phrase.
To me, that's fanaticism.
XJay Ambrose is director of editorial policy for Scripps Howard Newspapers and can be reached at AmbroseJ(at)shns.com