DAN K. THOMASSON Facing up to realities before Sept. 11



WASHINGTON -- After all of the finger-pointing, recriminations and second-guessing, one conclusion seems to be emerging from the national commission's inquiry into 9/11. Before the unprecedented attack on America, neither the Clinton administration in its eight years nor the Bush White House in its 230 days had a clue about how to deal with terrorism beyond the use of diplomacy and conventional law enforcement.
Moreover, the chances of congressional, public and international support for broad military action against the sanctuaries of Al-Qaida and related terrorist organizations before that fateful day would have been slim to none. A resolution either in the Congress or the United Nations to invade Afghanistan to force Osama bin Laden's protectors to give him up wouldn't have survived five minutes. In addition it would have brought worldwide denunciation.
To invade Afghanistan before 9/11 would have been like trying to have won a declaration of war against Japan before the attack on Pearl Harbor. In fact, Franklin Roosevelt's political opponents, as preposterous as it may sound, were convinced that FDR manipulated the events so Pearl Harbor would be an inviting target to win support for a war he knew the nation could not avoid.
Were there those within both administrations, such as former Bush terrorism expert Richard Clarke, who warned of the need to deal forcefully with bin Laden and his fellow fanatics? Of course, but they never seemed to come up with a viable plan to do so. In fact, there were several missed opportunities in the late '90s to arrest bin Laden. Clarke, who has accused Bush of an obsession with Iraq and negligence in dealing with terrorism even after 9/11, seems to have deliberately ignored or been woefully ignorant of the global political realities.
'They are here'
In his controversial new book, Clarke has described warning Secretary of State-designate Colin Powell during a briefing on terrorism in December 2000 that Al-Qaida had a presence in the United States. He reportedly told Powell that, "They are here." Powell's response during his appearance before the 9/11 commission was justifiably angry. He said that he had not yet taken over the State Department at the time of the briefing and if Clarke knew that there were Al-Qaida terrorists in the United States "running around" why hadn't he and his Clinton team done something about it?
The question emphasizes the dangers of this most favorite of Washington pastimes, scapegoating and blame fixing. Someone is always going to come forth with an "I told you so" allegation touching off a flurry of excitement that sells books but ignores political realities. Clarke opened his own appearance before the panel by apologizing to the survivors of those killed in 9/11. He said, "Your government failed you," and then presumptuously," I failed you." How does Webster define "messianic?"
Clearly, the Clinton administration looked to traditional intelligence and law enforcement responses to terrorism, relying on the FBI mainly to provide counterintelligence, detection and arrest, here and overseas. Military options seemed to center mainly around launching cruise missiles or some conventional airstrikes at suspected terrorist training camps. Neither approach was much of a deterrent, it turned out, with the FBI and CIA particularly muffing assignments by failing to follow up on leads that might have uncovered 9/11 plotters.
As for the Bush team, it seemed to be obsessed with Iraq, ignoring time and again advice from Clarke and others that there was no connection between Saddam Hussein and 9/11.
Weaknesses
The commission's work can only be worthwhile if, by identifying the weaknesses in the system, it enhances the ability to forestall future catastrophic events. It cannot do this, however, by broad hindsight pronouncements of condemnation. This nation and its leaders, despite any number of terrorist atrocities around the world that should have served as warning, was not politically ready to employ all its options before the horrendous attack on American soil.
This nation unfortunately responds only to immediate crisis on almost every issue, domestic and foreign and military.
In the end, the real blame should be placed on the nature of our society.
XDan K. Thomasson is former editor of the Scripps Howard News Service.