Killing Yassin won't make things better



By SHIBLEY TELHAMI
BALTIMORE SUN
For years, one Israeli government after another considered but in the end rejected killing Sheik Ahmed Yassin, the founder and spiritual leader of Hamas, the militant Islamist Palestinian organization. This has not stopped the government of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon from doing just that.
In the end, it is difficult to discern what has changed this Israeli equation and even harder to see how any good could come out of this action.
Israelis have an understandable hate for Hamas as an organization, which has carried out horrific attacks against innocent Israelis.
Consequences
But the logic in refraining from killing Yassin in the past was largely related to consequences:
USuch an attack would be less likely to reduce violence in the long term and probably would increase it in the short term.
UIt would focus attention on Israel's "targeted killings" policy, which has been strongly criticized by many around the world, especially by human rights organizations.
UIt would raise the stakes by targeting the highest levels of leadership.
UIt would make diplomatic efforts more difficult.
Has anything changed to make the consequences any different at the moment? Not likely.
First, there is the suggestion that past attacks on Hamas' leaders have, in fact, deterred the group from escalating its attacks.
It is hard to know for sure what best explains Hamas' actions.
But even assuming that its leaders in part worry about retaliation, the consequences in this case are likely to go in another direction: Yassin was not just another one of many Hamas leaders targeted in the past, he was the founder of the organization, its symbol and its central political leader.
Hamas' credibility will be seen by its followers and others in the region to be on the line. It is likely that it already has a plan to respond, since this attack could not have come as a surprise; Yassin barely missed being killed by another Israeli attack only months ago.
Such a response could include an escalation such as targeting Israeli leaders, which would in turn generate a massive Israeli reprisal. It is difficult to see how diplomatic efforts could have a chance in an environment of escalation.
Second, while Yassin was the key political leader and almost certainly had much say in the strategic direction of the organization and even decisions related to its military branch, he was not a nuts-and-bolts operational leader. His killing is unlikely to affect Hamas' operational capabilities at the same time that it is likely to generate more recruits.
Third, the most important impact of his killing is likely to be in the vacuum it will leave at the top of Hamas' political leadership. This will make Hamas more unpredictable, less disciplined and less amenable to enforceable short-term deals.
Fourth, unlike lower-ranked and lesser-known Hamas leaders Israel has targeted in the past, Yassin was a well-known figure in much of the Arab and Muslim world. Although many in that world don't condone Hamas' actions, especially the suicide bombings, many others unfortunately do.
Attraction
Still, one of the reasons Yassin was able to attract followers in the region was his defiance in the face of seeming weakness: He was a frail quadriplegic, a wheelchair-dependent old man who graduated from Israeli prisons and always sounded fearless.
He was for many a metaphor of the helpless state of affairs that Palestinians appear to endure in the eyes of most in the Middle East. This image, in the end, serves to garner sympathy for the wrong cause -- the cause of militancy instead of the cause of freedom through peaceful means.
All this comes as Sharon plans to visit Washington to coordinate his proposed unilateral "disengagement plan" with the Bush administration. If there was hope that such a plan could be implemented in the context of a modest tacit or formal agreement with the Palestinians, with the support of moderate Arab states, the prospects of such an outcome are now diminished.
XTelhami is a professor at the University of Maryland and a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. Distributed by the Los Angeles Times-Washington Post News Service