Why not debate?



Washington Post: Yes, Democratic candidate John F. Kerry's challenge to President Bush last weekend for a series of monthly debates was more political stunt than serious suggestion. The presumptive nominee's proposal was a bit hokey -- issued, as it was, in Quincy, Ill., the site of one of the Lincoln-Douglas debates. It was also a little hard to take Mr. Kerry's pontificating about the need to elevate the tone of the campaign. "Americans shouldn't have to put up with eight months of sniping," Kerry said -- this after referring to his opponents as "the most crooked, you know, lying group I've ever seen." And, yes, Kerry's zeal for an in-depth discussion of critical issues is tough to square with his dismissive attitude when Sen. John Edwards, D-N.C., proposed one-on-one debates at the end of the Democratic primary season. Somehow, we didn't hear Kerry talking then about how the "American people are hungry for a genuine conversation about the fundamental questions before us."
Good idea
And yet: He has a good idea. There will probably be three presidential debates this fall, the same number as four years ago. But the general election campaign, for better or worse, is already under way, and there is no shortage of critical issues on which voters ought to have the chance to compare and contrast the candidates. Real encounters between the two men would help voters far more than will any number of slick campaign ads in which the candidates hurl accusations that do little to explain where they would lead the country or to illuminate the differences between them. From the environment to civil liberties, from health care for the uninsured to reducing the deficit, from nuclear proliferation to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict -- suffice it to say, it would be easy to come up with numerous useful subjects for debate between Bush and Kerry. Most fundamentally: What are their visions of the proper role of the United States in the world today? And debates would provide a forum to prod candidates to address matters that both would rather duck -- for example, how they would tackle the growing demands on Social Security and Medicare.