DAN K. THOMASSON Separating by gender to improve education
WASHINGTON -- The Bush administration's bold step to lift restrictions on same-sex schools has far more potential for improving the nation's public schools than the No Child Left Behind Act, the centerpiece of the president's education initiative and a key part of his re-election campaign.
After 30 years of trying to dictate education policy on the basis of political correctness, the Department of Education has announced it will allow boys and girls to be taught separately on taxpayer money. The new regulations, which will take effect in a month or so, change the way the department interprets Title IX of the 1972 education act by allowing same-sex public schools or classes as long as they are evenhandedly applied between boys and girls. Only a few such institutions among the nation's 93,000 public schools exist now under special circumstances. Women's-rights activists are screaming.
Educators everywhere should rejoice, however, realizing (as they must if they are worth their salt) that both genders do much better in school when they are not distracted by the opposite sex, particularly at the earliest ages. With rare exception, boys and girls learn at different paces and most often use different abilities to reach the same point. It is just that simple, as most things are in education if politics are kept out of the mix.
Paranoia
When Johnny doesn't read as well as Janie or as quickly, his parents are most likely assured by some patronizing teacher or administrator that it is normal and that he is, like many (make that most) other males, a "late bloomer." That has been the key diagnosis most often used to justify a policy that stems not from reality but the paranoia of groups like the National Organization for Women who see separatism as a plot to deny females their hard-earned opportunities. That, of course, is pure balderdash. It subscribes to a silly theory that only boys would profit from the arrangement.
In fact, girls, when not being held back or distracted by the antics of the slower-moving males of the species, can move ahead at a far more productive pace. Boys without the often-embarrassing presence of the brighter girls can be taught at a rate and with techniques that are best suited to them. Girls generally are much more verbal. They take instruction, both orally and written, far better than the average boy when they are youngsters. Boys, on the other hand, have far shorter attention spans, get bored easier and respond more to show-and-tell than verbal instruction. As for the social aspects, that can be handled at recess or in convocations and other activities.
All this, of course, is no news to parents who are privileged enough to have a boy and a girl or several of each. Nor is the fact, to anyone who has been paying attention, that most of the public-school teachers are women who use female skills to teach mainly to other females, but must develop abilities not natural to them to reach the boys in the class, slowing down the entire process. My 8-year-old grandson, for instance, has been making wonderful strides this year after a lackadaisical performance last year because he has been lucky enough to get a male teacher who understands his needs. His sister, 10 and gifted, often complains about having to wait for the boys to catch up -- a similar gripe from two other granddaughters who are also extremely bright.
Personal experience
In case anyone wants to challenge my knowledge of this issue, I have four children and (soon to be) nine grandchildren -- four girls and five boys -- and was for a time actively involved in the PTA, enough to certify my qualifications, I would think, even without my own teaching certificate from many years ago.
While it would be impractical in many small communities to establish single-sex classes, there can be little excuse for not doing so in most urban and suburban districts where there are often two or even three sections of a single grade that could easily be segregated by gender with existing faculty and without a great deal of added expense, if any.
This is not meant to oversimplify the problems of the school system. There are a variety of issues that are complex in an increasingly complex society. But the administration's decision to take a commonsense approach to separate classes for boys and girls at least until they reach grade eight or nine is a giant stride in the right direction.
XDan K. Thomasson is former editor of the Scripps Howard News Service.
43
