BILL TAMMEUS Separating the saint from the shamrock
Scholars who try to separate St. Patrick fact from fiction say he wasn't Irish and wasn't -- at least at first -- named Patrick. Nor, they say, are many popular stories about him true.
But this fifth-century missionary, they say, was a pious man whose theology and life are well-worth studying for St. Patrick's Day.
"The real St. Patrick is far more challenging than the one associated with the shamrock and driving the snakes out of Ireland," says Bishop Raymond J. Boland of the Catholic Diocese of Kansas City-St. Joseph, a longtime student of St. Patrick's life and faith and a native of Ireland.
In his recent compendium, "Lives of the Saints," Richard P. McBrien, a University of Notre Dame theology professor, reports that Patrick was born in Roman Britain, not Ireland. He first went to Ireland as a slave in his midteens and spent six years there herding livestock. He was in his mid-40s before he returned to become bishop of Ireland.
Because of Patrick's slave years in Ireland, Boland says, "he got to know the language and customs of the people," which helped him convert the Celtic people from Druidism to Christianity. "In many ways, his captivity had turned out to be a novitiate preparing him to know and understand ... the people to whom he would return as a missionary."
Several sources say that Patrick's original name was Maewyn Succat and that he took on the name Patricius, or Patrick, when he became a priest. But as McBrien writes, the "historically verifiable" facts about Patrick are bare, and "even the place of his death and burial is uncertain."
His writings
It is possible, however, to gain at least some understanding of Patrick's beliefs and practices because, as Boland says, "he has left us two writings which are fully authentic." One has come to be called "The Confession of St. Patrick." The other is "Letter to the Soldiers of Coroticus."
It's also possible to know something of the Ireland Patrick felt called to evangelize. At the time Ireland's primary religion, Druidism, taught that the human soul was immortal and, at death, it moved from one person to another. Merriam-Webster's Encyclopedia of World Religions also says human sacrifice was at times part of Druid practice.
In Thomas Cahill's "How the Irish Saved Civilization," he describes the Ireland of St. Patrick's time this way: "This was an illiterate, aristocratic, semi-nomadic, Iron Age warrior culture, its wealth based on animal husbandry and slavery ... Ireland, splendidly isolated in the Atlantic and largely beyond the traffic of civilization, suffered few intrusive influences."
"It was," Boland says, "never conquered by the Romans and was untouched by their administrative abilities and their religion."
Several years ago, in Christian History (now Christian History & amp; Biography) magazine, journalist, author and playwright Mary M. Cagney, an Irish native, wrote that "if Christianity had come to Ireland with only theological doctrines, the hope of immortal life and ethical ideas -- without miracles, mysteries and rites -- it could have never wooed the Celtic heart."
Patrick understood the Celts' attraction to magic and miracles and took on the challenge directly as he sought to spread Christianity, Cagney writes.
She quotes a Patrick biographer from the late 600s whose no-doubt apocryphal but engaging story describes how Patrick once challenged Druids to a contest of "working wonders before the audience."
One of the Druids "invoked demons and brought about a dark fog over the land. Patrick said to the Druid, 'Cause the fog to disperse.' But he was unable to do it. Patrick prayed and gave his blessing, and suddenly the fog cleared and the sun shone. And through the prayers of Patrick ... flames of fire consumed the Druid.
"And the king was greatly enraged at Patrick because of the death of his Druid. Patrick said to the king, 'If you do not believe now, you will die on the spot for the wrath of God descends on your head.'
"The king summoned his council and said, 'It is better for me to believe than to die.' And he believed as did many others that day."
Quite the evangelist
Boland says Patrick "almost single-handedly converted the entire population of Ireland at the time. It was a stupendous work of evangelism. He achieved it without any bloodshed (tales of flaming Druids notwithstanding).
"That is most extraordinary. Apparently he was eminently successful in winning the local kings and chieftains to the faith, which, in turn, made it far easier, and maybe even expedient, for their subjects to embrace Christianity."
Scholars say St. Patrick's own approach to spirituality was insistently humble, but he was firm in his beliefs, including a conviction that slavery was wrong. Mary Cagney, in fact, calls Patrick "the first Christian to speak out strongly against" slavery. Patrick's opposition is not surprising, given his own history of being a slave. But he worked against it tirelessly.
Scholars say he once wrote an anti-slavery letter excommunicating a British man named Coroticus, who had captured some of Patrick's converts and enslaved them. Some scholars, in fact, credit Patrick with ending the Irish slave trade.
Patrick's humility is seen in much of his writing. In his "Confession," for instance, he regularly acknowledges his lack of education: "I still blush and fear more than anything to have my lack of learning brought out into the open. For I am unable to explain my mind to learned people."
Patrick, like leaders of the church at Rome, was a devoted Trinitarian, though most scholars say stories of him using the shamrock to demonstrate the Trinity are myth.
XBill Tammeus is an editorial page columnist for The Kansas City Star. Distributed by Knight Ridder/Tribune Information Services.
43
