Fair game: Sept. 11 shouldn't be off-limits in this election



Dallas Morning News: President Bush has come under fire for using images related to the Sept. 11 attacks in his campaign commercials. There are people out there -- ranging from relatives of victims to a firefighters union that endorsed Bush's Democratic rival, John Kerry -- who insist that the single most tragic day in U.S. history should be off-limits in this year's presidential campaign, and they're demanding that the ads be pulled off the air.
With all due respect, those people are wrong. In fact, there is no more important issue to be discussed in this election than how the United States -- and, specifically, this administration -- responded to the threat of terrorism. The events of that fateful day helped define the Bush presidency. They also reminded the American people of one of the great truths in politics -- that leadership often springs from how elected officials respond to challenging and difficult times.
Voters can decide
And so not only is it fair game for the president's re-election campaign to run commercials featuring images such as fallen firefighters and the ruins of the World Trade Center, it would be dishonest not to run them. Besides, if any voters are bothered by the ads, they can make their views known at the ballot box.
But that argument cuts both ways. Interestingly enough, just a few months ago, Americans were discussing virtually the same issue but from a radically different angle. Then, it was Democrats like Howard Dean, the former presidential candidate, who raised questions about whether the Sept. 11 attacks could have been prevented. Then, it was Republicans who tried to shut down debate by arguing that such questions were tasteless and irresponsible and that the whole issue should be, you guessed it, "off-limits."
The political parties can't have it both ways. The Democrats had it right the first time, just as Republicans have it right now. One simply can't ignore the events of Sept. 11, their impact on the country and how our elected officials responded to them. After all, what are elections for, if not to sort out the kinds of issues that separate leaders from followers?