Mahoning elections flap could have been avoided
The Mahoning County Board of Elections has decided that from this day forth it will notify the public if it does anything outside the norm pertaining to the conduct of elections.
We aren't impressed -- because the decision was prompted by the easily avoidable controversy that erupted Saturday over the board's handling of absentee ballots.
Given the tainted history of Mahoning County politics and past problems at the board of elections, director Michael Sciortino, a Democrat, and assistant director Tom McCabe, a Republican, should not be surprised that their decision to open absentee ballot envelopes on Saturday afternoon created a flap.
The action was red meat for the conspiracy theorists and resulted in two county officials, Prosecutor Paul Gains and Auditor George Tablack, trying to make political hay with the issue.
It also attracted the attention of a member of Ohio Secretary of State Kenneth Blackwell's staff.
Public reaction
All this could have been avoided had Sciortino and McCabe taken a moment to ask themselves this: "How will the public react if we open the absentee ballots on Saturday afternoon instead of the usual Monday before the Tuesday election?"
In just about any other county in Ohio, that question would not even have been asked. But this is Mahoning County, where public suspicion of all things government runs deep.
As The Vindicator detailed in a front page story Monday, the decision to open the absentee ballots Saturday afternoon was triggered by a series of events that began when elections officials were conducting a test of the optical scanning device that reads the paper ballots. They found that the absentee ballots were one-sixteenth of an inch too wide, which resulted in the scanner rejecting every third one.
Elections officials tried trimming the test ballots, but the scanner still kept rejecting some.
It was then decided to reprogram the optical scanner so it would accept the wider ballots. This solution worked well with ballots in the test pack, but the officials weren't sure how well it would work with actual absentee ballots that had been folded when they were returned to the elections board in envelopes.
McCabe says he made the decision that all the absentee ballots should be opened on Saturday afternoon. Sciortino and six other elections workers, three Democrats and three Republicans, were on hand.
The goal was to remove the ballots from the envelopes and flatten them as much as possible with weights to remove the creases, so as to ensure their unimpeded passage through the optical scanner.
But it is the decision to open the ballots on Saturday, rather than on Monday as has been done in recent years, that had the rumor mill churning.
In addition, by running 240 ballots through the scanner -- out of a total of 5,600 absentees -- elections officials fed the conspiracy theory that a vote count was being conducted. There was no count and no tabulation. All that McCabe and his colleagues were doing was making sure the ballots went through the scanner cleanly.
To its credit, the elections board held a news conference Sunday to explain what had transpired, and asked the secretary of state to send a representative to review its actions.
Thus on Monday, when the rest of the absentee ballots were opened, there were several people on hand to observe.
That's how it should have been at the outset.
43
