HOW HE SEES IT Marriage amendment speaks for itself
By ERIC SHUMSKY
WASHINGTON POST
WASHINGTON -- Proponents of the Federal Marriage Amendment -- the leading candidate for a constitutional ban on gay marriage -- claim that it would permit states to recognize civil unions. Rep. Marilyn Musgrave, R-Colo., the amendment's original sponsor, maintains that it "allows for civil unions if they are enacted by state legislatures, but they cannot be imposed by the courts."
After President Bush announced his support for a constitutional amendment, White House Press Secretary Scott McClellan said that the president agrees with Musgrave's claim, while stopping short of endorsing the specific wording of her version. And a variety of media outlets have repeated the same assertion as though it were fact. It is not.
On the contrary, the language in the Musgrave amendment would render civil unions -- as well as domestic partnerships -- meaningless.
Here's the text: "Marriage in the United States shall consist only of the union of a man and a woman. Neither this Constitution or the constitution of any State, nor state or federal law, shall be construed to require that marital status or the legal incidents thereof be conferred upon unmarried couples or groups."
Say that Oregon enacted a law recognizing civil unions. If the Musgrave amendment were adopted, that law would have no effect. The amendment says that state law can't be interpreted as granting to unmarried couples the "legal incidents" of marriage -- that is, the legal rights that traditionally accompany marriage -- which is precisely what a civil union does.
Power play
Musgrave argues that the amendment would only prevent "unelected judges" from "imposing" gay marriage, while protecting a state legislature's prerogatives. To her, this is about legislative vs. judicial power. But the amendment doesn't mention courts or legislatures. Apparently the word "construe" is meant to signal that judicial authority is at issue, on the theory that courts are the ones that "construe" laws. Even if that interpretation were tenable, the Musgrave formulation is an unusually oblique way to amend the Constitution.
If the amendment's supporters truly wished to preserve the states' ability to recognize civil unions, they could easily do so. They could remove the phrase "or the legal incidents thereof" from the second sentence; with that modification, states could still confer "legal incidents" of marriage. Alternatively, the second sentence could be deleted altogether. Or clearer still, the amendment could state plainly that civil unions are allowed: "Nothing in this Amendment shall be interpreted to prevent States from providing legal benefits, other than marriage, to unmarried couples."
Instead of clarifying the text, Musgrave (along with former judge Robert H. Bork, one of the drafters) has fallen back on arguing that the courts can figure out what Congress and the voters intended. Apart from the deep ironies in this argument (why rely on the courts if the amendment is meant to rein in "activist judges," and why are conservatives, who have long asserted that statutory interpretation begins and ends with the text, advocating murky inquiries into legislative intent?), it's odd to opt for vagueness over clarity in drafting a constitutional amendment.
Heavy burden
The amendment's drafters admit that the process was "messy," and meant to satisfy numerous groups with different interests. But whatever the merits of gay marriage, those who wish to amend the Constitution bear a heavy burden of ensuring that the policies they would enshrine are clearly and accurately reflected in the text they propose. Whether the drafters of the amendment were careless or disingenuous, they have fallen far short of that obligation.
X The author is a lawyer in Washington.
43
