Youngstown city workers should temper demands
Granted, it has been more than a year since Youngstown's police officers and firefighters canvassed the city seeking support for a 0.5 percent increase in the income tax, but there is one thing about that campaign we certainly would not have forgotten: the safety forces telling the voters that they were expecting a relatively large pay raise if the issue passed.
We don't remember that happening because it never did.
We do recall Mayor George M. McKelvey, city council and the unions representing the police and firefighters stating the need for the tax increase as a life-or-death proposition. And we definitely recall the promises made to bring back laid-off policemen and firefighters with the additional revenue.
But an annual 4.5 percent pay raise plus 60 cents more per hour?
That's what the police patrol union is seeking in its new labor contract. The union also is unwilling to make any changes in health-care benefits.
For his part, the mayor wants to freeze wages for about 150 patrolmen and women in each year of the three-year contract. And he wants the officers to contribute toward their health insurance premiums, make copayments on doctor and hospital visits, and make higher copayments on prescriptions.
Political hardball?
Is McKelvey simply playing political hardball? No. His attempt to exact concessions from the police is based on the financial reality of city government.
Year-end figures for 2003 show a $900,000 deficit in the operating fund.
That, coupled with the economic difficulties being faced by the state of Ohio, means that pay raises for public employees are a luxury Youngstown, or any other local government for that matter, cannot afford.
In pushing for the tax increase, police officers and firefighters talked about the need to bring back laid-off safety forces. They warned residents of the danger of having understaffed police and fire departments.
They did not say, "Pass this tax increase because we deserve a pay raise." Of course, no one should be surprised that they didn't.
And yet, a little over a year later, that's exactly what the patrolmen and women are demanding.
For the past three years they received raises of 4 percent a year and 30 cents more per hour. By contrast, many private sector workers who pay income tax in the city have not only had their wages frozen, but have had to contribute even more toward their health insurance.
That's the reality of today's economy -- a reality that seems lost on the public sector.
What the mayor is seeking is not unreasonable, given Youngstown's declining tax base and the growing number of residents who do not pay income tax. Suburbanites working in the city are the ones bearing an increasing burden.
Standard
Because the patrol officers' contract becomes the standard for labor agreements with other unions in city government, the McKelvey administration should not give in to the police demands.
A state fact finder conducted hearings on the contract impasse last week and will issue a report in the next two weeks.
We have long railed at the inability of such individuals, arbitrators included, to recognize that government isn't some bottomless money pit. Time and again communities have warned of economic disaster if union demands had to be met, but their pleas have fallen on deaf ears.
We wonder how these fact finders and arbitrators would react if the communities in which they live were operating in the red and had to give public employees pay raises.
It is noteworthy that for two years in a row, the city of Youngstown has ended with a operating deficit: In 2002, it was $1.6 million; in 2003, $900,000. Given that not too long ago the city was under state-mandated fiscal watch because it could not make ends meet, we have no doubt that officials of the state auditor's office are paying close attention to what is going on in City Hall.
McKelvey's desire for a three-year freeze may seem extreme, but he is merely responding to what he sees as the challenges confronting his administration this year.
On Dec. 1, nonunion workers in the city were put on a copayment plan that does not seem overly burdensome: 10 percent of the monthly premium that the city pays for each employee's health benefits; $10 for doctor office visits; $35 for urgent care visits; $50 for emergency room visits (it is waived if the patient is admitted to the hospital); $8 on generic prescription drugs and $15 on brand-name prescriptions.
No copayments
The police contract that expired at the end of November does not have a copayment for health insurance or doctor or hospital visits. Officers make $5 copayments on generic prescriptions and $10 on brand-name prescriptions.
It is clear that patrol officers have not had to make many sacrifices, even when the national economy was in a tailspin.
If the fact finder sides with the police union, we would hope that the men and women in blue remember the promises they made to the voters of the city of Youngstown when they were seeking the half-percent income tax increase.
At the very least, all the unions representing city government employees should agree to a one-year extension of their existing contracts to give the mayor and city council time to stabilize Youngstown's finances.
43
