Yes. Undocumented workers make a contribution to our society
Yes. Undocumented workers make a contribution to our society
By ALLAN WERNICK
NEW YORK DAILY NEWS
The nation's immigration laws aren't working, and that makes for a situation full of danger. Undocumented immigrants are at constant risk of being exploited, and their fear of civil authority makes them reluctant to join the nation's fight against crime and the war on terrorism. As for the rest of us, having as many as 12 million of our neighbors living in the shadows is bad public policy.
That's why President Bush's plan for immigration reform and his proposal to offer undocumented workers temporary status deserve support.
President's motives
Cynics question whether the plan is just an election year ploy. But whatever the president's motives, his willingness to recognize the contributions undocumented workers make to our society and his proposing even limited relief for them is a positive step.
His plan offers them the chance to work legally and gives them protection from workplace abuses. And it will solve labor shortages in industries like agriculture and child care. The alternatives -- mass deportations and penalizing employers -- just aren't practical solutions.
Some critics complain that the Bush plan rewards illegality. But is that really fair? Businesses that hire undocumented workers also are breaking the law. Where's the public outcry over that?
Consumers will benefit from Bush's plan as well. Agribusiness, including wineries in New York and California, would collapse without these workers. And if we refuse to legalize undocumented workers, does that mean we have to divert limited resources from the war on terror to a war on immigrants and their employers?
American Dream
The president says immigration reform must reflect the American Dream. For that dream to become a reality, undocumented workers need permanent status. The Bush plan offers hope for struggling immigrant workers, even though it doesn't provide a clear path to a green card.
Working every day with the undocumented, I see how they yearn for a way up from the underground. They are willing to abide by our laws, but in return they want to live free. For them, Bush's plan is a good start.
X Allan Wernick writes the New York Daily News' immigration advice column. Distributed by Knight Ridder/Tribune Information Services.
43
