HOW HE SEES IT Needed: new immigraton laws
By PAUL CAMPOS
SCRIPPS HOWARD NEWS SERVICE
TIJUANA, Mexico -- No one has a very good idea of how many people live in this city. The official population is over 2 million, but by some estimates the actual figure is perhaps twice that. On a Saturday afternoon, a friend and I are driven from San Diego County into the heart of Tijuana itself -- a trip that, in this direction, is as easy as driving to your neighborhood grocery store.
No customs procedure impedes travelers from El Norte ("the North"). The government of the state of Baja California is only too eager to draw in the American dollars that help sustain the local economy. The return trip is a different matter: Driving back into the United States through the main customs checkpoint at San Ysidro often takes an hour or more. We therefore choose to walk back across the border.
Reward
While doing so, we encounter evidence of another important element of the local economy: Posters issued by the U.S. government that announce a $5 million reward for information leading to the capture of the notorious Arellano brothers, who are said to control Baja California's lucrative drug smuggling trade, almost all of which flows into El Norte.
Despite the immense profits produced by the drug trade, Baja California's main export to the north remains its labor force, legal and illegal. Every day a wave of humanity makes its way north, with proper documentation or without, to perform work that Americans will not do, or at least will not do at salaries that Mexican workers eagerly accept.
Immigration policy is an extremely complex issue, and therefore one that is particularly prone to political exploitation by people across the political spectrum. What no one wants to acknowledge is that, in places such as Southern California, immigrants -- especially immigrants from Latin America -- are increasingly taking on the role played by the Germanic tribes in the late Roman Empire.
As imperial wealth made them decadent and materialistic, the Romans found it convenient to "outsource" the fighting of their wars and the building of their cities to the energetic peoples they had conquered. After a few generations, the more entrepreneurial members of this mercenary labor force came to the conclusion that, since they were doing the empire's dirty work, they ought to share more fully in its spoils.
Given that admittedly distant historical parallel, it's worth contemplating that many members of our armed forces currently fighting in the Middle East are not United States citizens, and that some of these soldiers are essentially exchanging military service for the eventual promise of citizenship.
Vice versa
For now, armies of Mexicans and other Central Americans mow our lawns, cook our meals, rear our children, and even fight our wars, without asking for a great deal in return. As a result, border areas such as Tijuana and San Diego have become de facto internationalized zones, where Central America spills into the United States, and vice versa.
This is not a sustainable long-term situation, either economically or politically. By tolerating the exploitation of a huge pool of illegal immigrant workers, the governments of the United States and Mexico trade short-term political and economic expedience for long-term social health.
The solution, to the extent there is one, will require constructing an enforceable immigration policy, and then actually enforcing it. America's current policy is based on the fiction that our immigration laws could be enforced without fundamentally altering who does the work that Americans don't want to do. As such, it is a dispiriting example of what happens when governments and peoples lack the will to look unpleasant facts in the face.
XPaul Campos is a law professor at the University of Colorado.
43
