Angelo, Tsagaris must revisit county administrator action
Absent actual proof -- a tape recording of conversations or a calendar showing the dates and times of the meetings -- that someone in the Trumbull County Prosecutor's Office had given them the green light to act, we aren't willing to accept the explanation from commissioners Joseph Angelo and James Tsagaris as to how Anthony Carson came to be appointed county administrator. And neither should the law-abiding residents of Trumbull County.
It isn't enough for Angelo and Tsagaris to say that someone in the prosecutor's office offered them advice on making the appointment and giving Carson, who continues to serve as the purchasing director, a $12,741 raise. He is now earning $61,943.
The public should demand that the commissioners identify the individual in the prosecutor's office who, in effect, told them that it was OK to act in a way that violates Ohio's open meetings law. The so-called Sunshine Law is clear: Public bodies are permitted to meet in executive session (private) to discuss such personnel matters as employment and salaries, but they must take a formal vote on such matters in a public meeting.
Not sure
When asked by The Vindicator if Prosecutor Dennis Watkins had given them the green light to step around state law, Angelo replied, "I'm not sure who it was."
Why not? Doesn't he and Tsagaris have a record of the contacts they had with the prosecutor's office? Aren't there telephone logs to show whether calls were made?
For the record, neither Watkins nor one of his assistant prosecutors, James Misocky, agrees with what the commissioners are alleging. Indeed, they contend that they had no knowledge of Carson's appointment as county administrator. Watkins notes that he was discussing the vacancy, created with the resignation of Roselyn Ferris, with a candidate interested in the job. Misocky says he met with Angelo and Tsagaris during an executive session Dec. 10, but the commissioners indicated they were going to appoint Carson office manager, not administrator. Also, there was no discussion of a specific pay increase for the purchasing director.
Angelo says he and Tsagaris made several personnel changes in their office on Dec. 10, but the third commissioner in office at the time, Michael O'Brien, says he had "absolutely no idea" such moves were being made. O'Brien was serving out his final days in county government. He began a four-year term as mayor of Warren at the beginning of this month.
Nonetheless, he was still in county government at the time of Carson's appointment, as was Ferris, who left her job on Dec. 31.
How did the appointment come about? Angelo says the commissioners wrote a letter authorizing the personnel moves and entered two -- Carson's was not one of them -- in the commissioners' official journal. The journal is a record of the votes that authorize action, such as hiring and pay increases.
A letter clearly does not satisfy the requirement of state law that a public meeting be held in which votes are cast. The county prosecutor agrees with this reading of the law.
Legal challenge
Thus, Carson's appointment as county administrator could certainly be open to legal challenge.
We would urge commissioners Angelo and Tsagaris to revisit the entire process and as a starting point publicly advertise the job. Who is to say that Carson is the most qualified or the most appropriate individual to hold such an important position?
Carson's appointment has the stench of another backroom deal in county government.
43
