House should be honest about resolution's purpose
If the Ohio House is really concerned about women's health, members will give short shrift to a resolution introduced by Rep. Jean Schmidt that purports to discover whether there is a link between abortion and breast cancer.
The measure, backed by Ohio Right to Life, would create a six-member task force -- with five members appointed by Speaker Larry Householder, an ardent opponent of abortion -- that would be directed to come up with its findings and make recommendations by Nov. 30. A political committee cannot determine in eight or nine months what takes trained scientists and epidemiologists years to research -- unless the committee's conclusion has already been reached, its recommendations already decided.
Schmidt insists her resolution -- cosponsored by 37 members of the House, 33 of them endorsed by Ohio Right to Life -- is a matter of women's health rather than anti-abortion politics, but it's really a transparent attempt to throw more fuel on the anti-abortion fire.
The truth: Rather than indicating the true picture of the research on factors that increase the risk of breast cancer, the resolution mentions only one study which has come under fire from reputable scientists around the country. But the supporters of the resolution apparently don't want women to know what the American Cancer Society and National Cancer Institute have to say on the subject. In fact, during a meeting with The Vindicator representatives of Ohio Right to Life suggested that no one but their organization cared about this issue and a woman's right to know "the truth."
But truth be told, the findings of the American Cancer Society, the National Institutes of Health and other medical experts who have no predetermined position on this issue do not support Ohio Right to Life's viewpoint. It's just that Ohio Right to Life and the House members supporting Schmidt's resolution are more interested in fear-mongering than in learning the truth.
& quot;The scientific evidence does not support the association between induced abortion and breast cancer, & quot; says Joann Schellenbach, the national director of medical and scientific communication for the American Cancer Society. & quot;We would advise women considering abortion that they should not be concerned with an added risk of breast cancer. & quot;
If the supporters of this unnecessary measure were truly interested in women's health, they would express their concern about the 7,300 women who died from lung cancer in Ohio in 2000 (compared to the 1,900 who succumbed to breast cancer) by vigorously supporting laws to keep tobacco products out of the hands of young girls. Though we recognize how difficult that is for politicians like Schmidt whose campaign funds are enriched by the Philip Morris Co.
Ohio Right to Life certainly has the right to dissuade women from having abortions -- even when it comes to passing off questionable research as fact.
But until the General Assembly is willing to mandate similar studies of every other health condition that affects women -- or men or children -- or to require every physician to tell every one of his or her patients about every alleged risk factor linked to every disease, we would suggest that representatives and senators will do a far better job of serving their constituents by staying in the Statehouse and out of our doctors' offices.
43
