DEBATING THE WAR
DEBATING THE WAR
Washington Post: Senate Minority Leader Trent Lott was aghast Thursday when Majority Leader Tom Daschle asked President Bush to clarify the administration's plans for the next stages of the war. "How dare Senator Daschle criticize President Bush while we are fighting our war on terrorism, especially when we have troops in the field!" Mr. Lott demanded to know.
Is this the same Mr. Lott who, when U.S. pilots were in harm's way over Iraq in December 1998, said, "I cannot support this military action in the Persian Gulf at this time"? Is this the Sen. Lott who, in the spring of 1999, sounding very much like Sen. Daschle this past week, asked President Clinton to clarify his strategy in the war under way at that time in Kosovo? "I think the president needs to show leadership," Sen. Lott said then. "I think the president needs to tell Congress what the plans are. There are a lot of unanswered questions here."
There's a point here more important than one senator's inconsistency. The real questions are whether Congress has a role to play in debating foreign and defense policy and what the limits of that role should be in wartime. To the first question, we can't imagine any believer in democracy answering with anything but a resounding yes. The war against anti-American terrorists is fundamental to U.S. survival, and we certainly hope an overwhelming majority of Congress will continue to agree with President Bush on that point. But it also raises difficult questions. Who precisely is the enemy? What is the connection between fighting terrorists and stopping weapons of mass destruction? Should the target be Islamic terrorists in particular? Is pre-emption justified in self-defense? How about assassination? Where are the boundaries between military action and law enforcement?
Stifling debate: Sen. Lott now would have us believe that raising such questions is divisive; but what's divisive, and dangerous, is stifling debate for political gain. Of course politicians must be cognizant of troops in the field and careful not to give away secrets. But Congress has not only the right but also an obligation to probe and challenge Bush administration policies, just as Sen. Lott was right to question President Clinton on strategy in Kosovo. Such probing should lead to better policies, which in the long run help troops in the field most of all.
That doesn't mean the critics are going to be right always, or even mostly. Mr. Daschle's comments seemed to us unexceptionable: He said that the war has been a success so far, that it won't be a total success as long as Al-Qaida and Taliban leaders remain at large and that the administration should define and explain its goals as the war expands. It's hard to imagine President Bush disagreeing with any of that, his spokesman's snide potshot at Mr. Daschle notwithstanding.
NO TO A COUP
Scripps Howard: The Bush administration is admirably resisting the traditional American temptation to meddle in Latin America.
When Venezuelan military officers asked if the administration would support a coup against their rambunctious president, Hugo Chavez, the State Department said no. What was interesting about the request and the response was that they were both public. The military has made no secret of its unhappiness with Chavez, and four senior military officers have already called on him to resign.
Chavez, who himself tried an unsuccessful coup in 1992, was elected president in 1999 and, with the help of a tame legislature and judiciary, drafted a new constitution that gave him a six-year term expiring in 2007.
Populism: He was elected on a domestic program of populism and government spending that worked as long as oil prices were rising. With the oil industry in a slump, Chavez has had to cut spending and, in desperation, allowed the bolivar to float, which scared off foreign investors and left Venezuela facing possible inflation of 30 percent to 40 percent.
Chavez fancied himself Latin America's leading leftist, and even though the United States is Venezuela's leading trading partner, his foreign policy consisted of tweaking us. He has buddied up to Fidel Castro, visited Iraq and Libya and denounced the U.S. air campaign in Afghanistan as terrorism.
His confrontational style has angered the press, the church, the trade unions and the military. According to a Venezuelan pollster, if an election were held today Chavez would only get 25 percent of the vote.
Clearly, there's a case for getting him out of office. The problem with democracy is sometimes the wrong person gets elected, but a coup is not the solution. Venezuela has been a democracy since 1958 and it should stay that way. State Department spokesman Richard Boucher is absolutely right when he says, "Those who may want change, political change, need to pursue it democratically and constitutionally."
Chavez could either be impeached, voted out in 2004 when the constitution provides for a special mid-term election or defeated when his regular term expires.
In a welcome turn of events, every country in Latin America but one is a democracy, and, it is hoped, that exception, Cuba, won't last much longer.
43
