Courts should not interfere with mission of Supermax
The Ohio State Penitentiary in Youngstown, commonly known as the Supermax prison, is home to the worst of the worst criminals in the state, which is why the Taft administration must not let a federal judge redefine the mission of the facility.
U.S. District Court Judge James Gwin wants the state to reform its system for sending inmates to the super-maximum security prison and suggests that the place may be too confining. While we agree that even society's dregs have a right to due process, we are unwilling to leave it up to the courts to decide if the OSP is overly tough. The whole point in having the Supermax, where prisoners are kept in solitary confinement 23 hours a day and are shackled when they are outside their cells, is deterrence.
The idea is to convey to guests of Ohio's corrections system a message that the murder of guards, assaulting other prisoners or guards, gang activity and even fighting will not be tolerated. It is not that complicated. How else is the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction supposed to maintain peace in its less restrictive prisons?
Reality: For Judge Gwin of Akron to opine that conditions at the Ohio State Penitentiary, located on Youngstown's East Side, "impose an atypical and significant hardship" is to ignore the reality of today's criminal class. A goodly number aren't simply misguided, deprived individuals who, through no fault of their own, crossed the straight-and-narrow. They are murderers, rapists and armed robbers who have shown no remorse and who perpetrate evil even while behind bars.
Shouldn't there be a facility where such individuals experience the kind of "significant hardship" that so disturbs Judge Gwin? We believe there should -- and we believe that the Supermax prison in Youngstown fits the bill.
The state of Ohio has agreed to make changes satisfying health care and mental health issues and has even promised to build an open-air recreation area to replace the ventilated room that now serves as outdoor recreation for the inmates.
But before the state proceeds with the development of the open-air area, we would urge officials of the department of rehabilitation and correction to meet with Youngstown city officials and with East Side residents to reassure them that the community will not be in harm's way.
As for the judge's concern about prisoners' due process rights, the state plans to implement guidelines this month that will improve its inmate classification system. The fact that the OSP took in 45 inmates in 2001 and released 212 suggests to us that the Supermax is not being used arbitrarily and has not become a dumping ground for inmates.
The judge has given lawyers for Ohio and those representing inmates two weeks to file recommendations for how to revise the classification system.
The Taft administration should take this case all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court if Judge Gwin attempts to undermine the mission of the Supermax.
43
