YOUNGSTOWN Tax abatements

CompanyJobsJobsJobs Income Real propertyReal propertyPersonal propertyPersonal propertyPercentageYearpromisedcreatedretainedTaxes paidinvestmentinvestmentinvestmentinvestment made abatement, real andgrantedpromisedmadepromisedpersonal propertyAccuForm Pattern Inc.1897$9,606.55$600,000$600,000$400,000$600,00075%2000Airborne Express**4530$2,681.96$515,000$576,483$200,000$127,06575%1991Allied Consolidated50087$49,741.07$3,000,000$3,486,325$500,000$420,000100%1994B & amp;BContractors and Developers6518$24,300.65$700,000$945,338$150,000$390,207100%1994Berry Distributing24822$7,996.89$240,000$442,944$265,000$338,700100%1994Boston Metal Products Corp.25520$39,736.41$-$-$1,430,000$2,385,453100%1992BRILEX Industries10416.5$29,801.65$-$-$420,000$36,00075%2000Cantar/Polyair Corp.15012663$70,850.56$4,000,000$4,907,859$5,500,000$5,028,550100%1994Coronado Steel Co.5314$9,211.12$189,500$200,000$45,500$50,00075%2000Crab Creek Industrial Village18850$47,116.90$1,000,000$685,000$300,000$285,000100%1994D & amp;L Energy Inc.10712$8,829.80$430,000$430,000$40,000$-100%1996Diver Steel City Tire Shredder3336$10,763.07$-$-$510,000$510,00063%1993Entire-Enviro Inc.4040$630.24$800,000$1,500,000$2,325,000$475,00075%1999Exal Corp.1251070$97,631.11$3,000,000$3,205,000$16,100,000$16,100,000100%1994FFAP Limited406$500.16$500,000$341,249$50,000$18,17975%2000Fab-Art Inc.10060$22,861.04$431,000$431,000$600,000$638,000100%1993Federal Express7765$64,019.10$1,200,000$1,425,920$-$103,560100%1992Fireline Inc.121149$42,140.00$465,000$584,000$535,000$845,648100%1996Fireline Inc. II3118$13,571.09$322,100$404,101$1,409,895$712,08475%2000Gasser Chair Co.52680$53,601.76$1,925,000$1,252,441$800,000$1,308,731100%1994GBS Computer Systems201735$53,564.54$729,600$1,048,152$1,900,000$1,135,240100%1991Graybar Electric Co.51220$21,797.00$700,000$1,202,945$1,100,000$1,780,067100%1991Graybar Electric Co. II45490$33,377.00$6,700,000$7,014,729$21,050,000$24,025,33475%2000Industrial Mill Maintenance Inc.6486$30,206.55$190,000$80,000$130,000$297,31483%1991Insulated Glass Specialties800$3,238.61***$3,000,000$3,000,000$200,000$-75%2000LM Engineering Inc./ Precision Foam Fabrication Inc.252028.5$21,798.82$850,000$1,500,000$241,000$334,94875%2000Miller Buckeye Biscuit Co.100232$59,961.21$450,000$1,031,100$4,173,000$3,920,000100%1997Nannicola Wholesale Co.n/a741$35,855.85n/a$1,540,515n/a$887,985100%1997North Star Steel22540$57,965.00$441,725$717,135$5,331,570$7,729,30963%1990North Star Steel II11434$464,770.00$2,406,000$-$28,882,000$28,359,56975%1999Northern States Metals2004120$13,945.52$2,500,000$2,551,951$2,500,000$1,226,438100%1994Paragon Industries3511745$22,941.43$-$-$250,000$79,586100%1994Parker Hannifin (Commercial Intertech)504476$96,291.65$5,600,000$5,737,997$5,550,000$9,663,534100%1994Precision Platen Machine2.550$29,801.00$500,000$542,000$655,000$676,00075%1999R.A.S. Manufacturing Co.507242$55,515.03$2,520,000$2,675,937$580,000$716,484100%1997Redlich Auto Service Inc.729$12,469.36$415,000$550,000$125,000$236,000100%1996Republic Ceiling Systems Distributors (Republic Gypsum Supply Co.)16130$9,863.21$420,000$486,500$310,000$588,00063%1991Roehlen Industries3328$35,936.41$260,000$340,927$50,000$120,01463%1991Rohan & amp; Joseph Management (PPG Industries)305$2,369.38$90,000$-$-$-100%1993Schenley Properties39180$4,929.82$2,800,000$3,250,000$275,000 Combined with real property75%2000Schoen Industries640$1,677.10$-$111,069$70,000$48,163100%1996Struthers Metal Service12158$14,948.56$500,000$856,146$55,000$558,369100%1994Taylor-Winfield Corp.101474$78,192.79$5,000,000$5,900,000$2,500,000$2,231,860100%1997Toys R Us9018175$196,052.80$8,000,000$10,838,031$21,000,000$50,972,976100%1991Tri-State Laboratories12019$4,120.49$600,000$600,000$300,000$300,000100%1992United Foundaries0n/a101$75,276.14$-$-$2,500,000$969,15375%1999WACO Scaffolding & amp; Equipment14.5412$15,591.66$600,000$720,137$500,000$-75%2000Youngstown Rubber Products10013$6,557.81$175,000$195,000$500,000$50,000100%1994Youngstown Sinter Co.70690$13,824.36****$865,000$234,184$9,135,000$9,231,72163%1991Totals1,3891,3131,797$2,078,430.23$65,629,925$74,142,115$141,442,965$176,510,241*Involves abatements granted between 1990 and 2000.**An independent trucking contractor employs drivers under an agreement with the company. City income tax shows 35 trucking employees and three Airborne workers.***Accounts for Youngstown division before construction of new facility****Through April 30, 2000. As of May 1, reporting income tax under WCI Steel