States forced to collect for nursing-home care

Families often aren't told about hardship waivers, an AARP spokeswoman said.
CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR
ORLANDO, FLA. -- Ever since Judy Clifford's parents died, she had planned to move with her husband into their Nashville, Tenn., home, which she knew so well.
& quot;I felt like they were still there, & quot; says Ms. Clifford, who is retired. & quot;I could see my mother standing at the sink washing dishes and my daddy watching TV, and I wanted to stay in the house because of that. & quot;
Instead, the two-bedroom ranch-style home is for sale for 122,000, the subject of a bitter tug-of-war between the Cliffords and TennCare, Tennessee's healthcare program for the poor and uninsured. TennCare has laid claim to the home to recoup the cost of caring for Clifford's mother, who was on TennCare when she died three years ago.
In the face of soaring Medicaid costs, Tennessee and every other state are required to set up a Medicaid estate-recovery program. Many have been launched only recently, and some -- such as Tennessee's -- are becoming more aggressive. Often, they target the home because it's all that's left after beneficiaries have spent their assets to pay for nursing-home care.
But the varied ways in which states are going after these assets have produced confusion, anger and even lawsuits. When a loved one dies, some families are stunned to lose the home, too, advocates say.
Here are concerns
& quot;It's fine that these programs are required by federal law, but people need to know the rules of the game, & quot; says Wendy Fox-Grage, policy adviser with the AARP Public Policy Institute. & quot;We're concerned that families are not being notified. & quot;
An AARP study determined that the inconsistency of notification was such a concern that the organization commissioned the American Bar Association to do another study focused on consumer protections, she says. Results are expected this spring.
States base their programs on a 1993 federal law mandating that they recover what Medicaid spends on a beneficiary's long-term care. Congress approved the law to prevent states from forcing the sale of beneficiaries' homes while they were still living, in case their conditions improve and they can return home, says Mary Kahn, spokeswoman for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
& quot;The point of the program is to be there for people with no alternative, & quot; she says. & quot;If the state is able to recover expenses that they put forth, then that money will be there for the next person down the line who desperately needs help. & quot;
States generally notify families about their estate-recovery programs upfront when a beneficiary applies for Medicaid and then again when the beneficiary dies, during the judicial claims process, says Ms. Fox-Grage of AARP. But often, states provide the information as part of a long list of things a Medicaid applicant should know. Not all states inform families of the hardship waivers available to them, either, she says.
Another example
James Napier and his family were shocked to receive a letter from the state of Texas about his ex-wife's home after she died in May 2005. She spent the last two months of her life in a nursing home. Now the family owes Medicaid 5,600, and the government has laid claim to the home Mr. Napier and his ex-wife bought together in 1977, which now is in poor condition and valued at 2,500. Texas's estate-recovery program took effect at about the same time Napier's ex-wife died. The state rejected the family's application for a hardship waiver.
& quot;No one had any idea, & quot; says Napier, a media consultant in Hot Springs, Ark. & quot;If they had told us up-front that to pay for nursing-home care we're going to want this back out of your estate, I know that we would have ... said we don't want your help. We'll find another way. & quot;
Altogether, estate-recovery programs earned 347 million in fiscal 2003, according to an AARP report. But the amounts varied widely: from 86,000 in Louisiana to nearly 54 million in California. The average amount recovered per estate was 8,116 nationally, but as little as 93 in Kentucky and as much as 25,139 in Hawaii.
These sums don't begin to pay for what Medicaid spends. Only eight states recovered more than 1 percent of long-term care expenses. But the report found that states are expanding their recovery programs.
The modest returns prompted Georgia to wait until this year to implement its program, says Fred Watson, president of the Georgia Health Care Association. Mr. Watson is concerned that people don't know about the program because it has received little publicity, and few social workers and hospital staffs know about it.
What's been tried
Some states have tried to remove themselves from the process altogether on grounds it could impoverish beneficiaries' families. In 2001, West Virginia filed suit against the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), challenging the law's constitutionality. A US circuit court ruled in 2002 in favor of HHS, noting that if states don't comply with Medicaid rules, they could risk losing their federal matching funds.
In Tennessee, soaring TennCare costs have pushed the state to hire a consulting firm to help collect information from enrollees.