Family determines Carroll's crying on video is faked

Monday, August 21, 2006 With a deadline set, her sister knew she'd be safe for the next 16 days. By PETER GRIER CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR Five Iraqi female detainees were released Jan. 26, along with some 450 male prisoners. Though U.S. officials denied this was in response to Jill's captors' demands, her family saw it as a hopeful sign. But four days later, Jill's twin sister, Katie, got a disturbing call from Amelia Newcomb, deputy foreign editor, who served as the Monitor's liaison to the family. The kidnappers had released another video, said Newcomb; and on this one, Jill was crying. Immediately Katie assumed the worst — that this was evidence her sister was being mistreated. She snapped on her television, and, indeed, saw a picture of a sobbing Jill. And in an instant, she felt much better. Jill was faking, Katie thought. She knew her sister. She knew that when Jill really cried, it was like the Nile at the crest of a flood. The tears would come so hard, Jill wouldn't even be able to see, if she didn't wipe them away. But this was different. This was ... restrained. Maybe the kidnappers were coaching Jill. Maybe she wasn't being physically mistreated. What mother said Katie wasn't the only family member to take heart from the ostensibly disturbing video. Mary Beth Carroll didn't think her daughter was crying, either. Clearly, Jill was being fed — her cheeks weren't sunken — and she was dressed in a neat hijab, which seemed in some manner a token of respect. Nine days later, a third video of Jill appeared on a Kuwaiti television station. This time, for the first time, her voice could be heard. "I am with the mujahedeen," she said. "I sent you a letter written by my hand, but you wanted more evidence, so we are sending you this letter now to prove I am with the mujahedeen." On Feb. 10, a day later, the owner of the Kuwaiti television station said that sources close to the kidnappers had told him there was a Feb. 26 deadline. Two whole weeks! The U.S. had that long to release all Iraqi women from its prisons, or else. To Mary Beth, that meant Jill's safety was guaranteed for the next 16 days. The day after the video came out, Mary Beth woke up in a good mood. After the daily worries she and the rest of the family had experienced, this was almost like being on vacation, she thought.